
Physics
Pattern formation by turbulent cascades
X. M. D. Wit, M. Fruchart, et al.
Discover how turbulent cascades can be harnessed to create patterns through a novel nonlinear mechanism. This exciting research, conducted by Xander M. de Wit, Michel Fruchart, Tali Khain, Federico Toschi, and Vincenzo Vitelli, reveals the role of odd viscosity in wavelength selection and its applications in nature.
Playback language: English
Introduction
The research question addresses whether turbulence, a chaotic state, can be used to generate patterns. Typically, pattern formation relies on the linear instability of a homogeneous state, leading to wavelength selection. This paper explores a different, fully nonlinear mechanism. The study's context is the understanding of turbulent cascades, which involve energy transfer across scales. The purpose is to show that by manipulating these cascades, specifically by introducing a non-dissipative arrest mechanism, patterns can be generated. The importance of this research stems from the ubiquity of turbulence in diverse systems and the potential for controlling pattern formation in these systems. The authors challenge the conventional understanding that turbulence is inherently structureless and propose a new perspective on pattern formation through a novel mechanism that relies on the nonlinear interaction of modes within the turbulent cascade. This research has implications for various fields, including fluid dynamics, plasma physics, and atmospheric science, where turbulent cascades are common occurrences. The key innovation lies in leveraging the non-dissipative nature of odd viscosity to arrest the cascade and induce pattern formation, contrasting with typical pattern formation mechanisms rooted in linear instabilities. Understanding this mechanism could provide a new way to control pattern formation in various natural and engineered systems.
Literature Review
The paper reviews existing literature on turbulent cascades, differentiating between direct and inverse cascades. It contrasts the proposed mechanism with the textbook picture of pattern formation from linear instabilities, referencing works on pattern formation outside equilibrium and the properties of odd viscosity in various systems. The authors cite previous research on turbulence in 2D and rotating fluids, where inverse cascades are observed, and discuss odd viscosity as a non-dissipative viscosity found in systems breaking time-reversal and inversion symmetry. The review also touches on prior work on rotating turbulence and its impact on cascade dynamics, setting the stage for a comparison with the novel mechanism involving odd viscosity. The literature review contextualizes the proposed mechanism within the broader field of turbulence and pattern formation, emphasizing its novelty and significance compared to established understanding.
Methodology
The study combines theoretical analysis with large-scale numerical simulations. The theoretical approach involves extending the Navier-Stokes equations to incorporate odd viscosity. This modified equation, a nonlinear diffusion equation with an antisymmetric cross-diffusion coefficient, allows for the study of the impact of odd viscosity on the energy transfer across scales. The authors utilize a generalization of the Taylor-Proudman argument to explain the two-dimensionalization of the flow in odd fluids. A scaling theory, based on dimensional analysis, is developed to predict the characteristic length scales involved in the pattern formation process. This theory considers both the eddy turnover time and the frequency of odd waves to determine the relevant time scales in different regimes. The numerical simulations involve integrating the modified Navier-Stokes equations using a parallelized pseudo-spectral solver. Simulations are conducted with and without odd viscosity to compare the resulting turbulent states and analyze the energy spectra and fluxes. The simulations explore scenarios with energy injection at different scales relative to the characteristic scale determined by odd viscosity to reveal the effects on cascade dynamics. A decomposition of the energy flux into homochiral and heterochiral channels is performed to understand the role of helicity conservation in the inverse cascade. This comprehensive methodology, combining analytical and computational methods, provides robust evidence for the proposed mechanism of cascade-induced pattern formation.
Key Findings
The study's key findings demonstrate that odd viscosity, a non-dissipative viscosity, can arrest both direct and inverse turbulent cascades at an intermediate scale, resulting in pattern formation. The simulations confirm the theoretical predictions, showing the emergence of vertically aligned structures of a characteristic size set by the odd viscosity. The characteristic length scales (k<sub>odd</sub> and k<sub>c</sub>) are identified and quantified using scaling theory. The numerical results show spectral condensation at intermediate scales, with the peak wavenumber (k<sub>c</sub>) agreeing with the theoretical predictions. The authors show that the ratio of odd viscosity to shear viscosity (ν<sub>odd</sub>/ν) controls the height of the spectral condensation peak. The analysis of energy flux reveals a flux-loop mechanism in the inverse cascade, where energy flows from small injection scales to large scales and back to smaller scales before dissipation. The study also presents a comparison between rotating turbulence and odd turbulence, highlighting the crucial difference in the order of direct and inverse cascades, explaining why pattern formation occurs only in odd fluids. Finally, the study extends the concept of cascade-induced pattern formation to other systems beyond fluids with odd viscosity, such as geophysical flows, plasma, and mass cascades.
Discussion
The findings address the research question by demonstrating a novel, fully nonlinear mechanism for pattern formation using turbulence. This contrasts with conventional mechanisms relying on linear instabilities. The significance of these results is that they offer a new understanding of pattern formation in turbulent systems and expand the possibilities of controlling pattern formation through manipulation of the cascade dynamics. The relevance to the field is considerable, impacting our understanding of pattern formation in various natural systems, including atmospheric flows, plasmas, and systems exhibiting mass cascades. The findings challenge the traditional view of turbulence as structureless chaos, revealing a potential for generating order from seemingly disordered systems. Further research could explore the broader applicability of this mechanism, investigating other types of waves and their influence on cascade dynamics. The study's findings open doors for further exploration into the manipulation of turbulent cascades for controlling pattern formation.
Conclusion
The paper presents a new mechanism for pattern formation driven by the non-dissipative arrest of turbulent cascades in fluids with odd viscosity. This mechanism is fully nonlinear and relies on the interaction between direct and inverse cascades, arrested by odd viscosity waves. The study combines theoretical analysis and large-scale simulations to demonstrate this mechanism and explores its potential applications in diverse systems. Future research could explore the potential of this mechanism in other wave turbulent systems, like optics and elasticity, as well as investigate the detailed dynamics of flux loops in inverse cascades.
Limitations
The study focuses primarily on idealized models of fluid turbulence. While the Navier-Stokes equations with odd viscosity are a reasonable approximation for certain systems, the real-world complexity of many natural systems may introduce additional effects not considered in this model. The scaling theory developed relies on certain assumptions, and deviations from these assumptions could lead to deviations from the theoretical predictions. While the simulations are large-scale, they still have limitations in terms of the achievable Reynolds numbers. Further research with higher Reynolds numbers would enhance the understanding of this mechanism in more realistic turbulent regimes.
Related Publications
Explore these studies to deepen your understanding of the subject.