The effects of sleep deprivation on cognitive flexibility: a scoping review of outcomes and biological mechanisms

Background: Sleep is vital for physical and mental health, yet sleep deprivation is widespread and may impair cognitive flexibility, leading to rigid thinking and slower decision-making. This scoping review synthesizes evidence on the impact of sleep deprivation or sleep loss on cognitive flexibility. Objective: To provide a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted effects of sleep deprivation on cognitive flexibility. Methods: Searches were conducted in PubMed, Web of Science, ClinicalKey, Cochrane, Scopus, SinoMed, and CNKI for studies evaluating effects of sleep deprivation on cognitive flexibility. Two researchers independently screened and extracted data and assessed quality using the MMAT. Results: Of 410 retrieved articles, 6 randomized controlled trials and 11 non-randomized studies were included, spanning children, adolescents, college students, clinicians, athletes, and other adults. Eight studies found that sleep deprivation reduces cognitive flexibility, six reported no significant impact, and two noted temporary improvements due to physical stress. One study highlighted that being overweight exacerbates negative effects. Conclusions: Sleep deprivation may predominantly impair accuracy rather than reaction time. Total sleep deprivation consistently reduces task-switching accuracy and cognitive flexibility, whereas partial sleep deprivation effects remain unclear. Biological mechanisms involve decreased cerebral oxygen supply, impaired cerebrovascular reactivity, and alterations in gene expression and hormone levels. More rigorous randomized trials with objective measures are needed to assess long-term impacts across populations and age groups.

Xuefeng Sun, Zihan Qu, Xiaotu Zhang, Ye Zhang, Xinye Zhang, Haifeng Zhao, Hongshi Zhang