logo
Loading...
Effectiveness of multifactorial and single interventions on safety climate and safe patient handling and movement practices: a cluster randomized controlled trial
Medicine and HealthScandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health

Effectiveness of multifactorial and single interventions on safety climate and safe patient handling and movement practices: a cluster randomized controlled trial

S. Buck, J. Sandqvist, et al.

Research conducted by Sebastian Buck, Jan Sandqvist, Emma Nilsing Strid, Nadine Karlsson, Paul Enthoven, Maria Andreassen, and Charlotte Wåhlin compared multifactorial and single safe patient handling and movement interventions across 46 Swedish healthcare units. Over 12 months, safety climate and handling practices improved in both groups, but the resource-intensive multifactorial approach offered minimal additional benefit. Hear what this cluster randomized trial reveals about improving patient-handling safety efficiently.... show more
Abstract
Objective: Evidence regarding the effectiveness of safe patient handling and movement (PHM) programs is limited. This study compared the effectiveness of a multifactorial intervention and a single intervention for safe PHM in the Swedish healthcare sector. Methods: This cluster randomized controlled trial included 46 healthcare units from Swedish hospital care units and nursing homes, randomized to a multifactorial or single safe PHM intervention. Primary outcomes were changes in safety climate, measured with the Nordic Safety Climate Questionnaire (NOSACQ-50), and PHM-specific practices, measured with SafePHM-14, over 12 months. Outcomes were analyzed using mixed models at the aggregated healthcare-unit level, adjusting for organization type. Results: Overall intervention-group differences were observed for management safety justice (NOSACQ-50 dimension 3, P=0.048) and workers’ safety commitment (dimension 4, P=0.026). However, there were no significant time × intervention-group interactions for any of the seven NOSACQ-50 dimensions or 14 SafePHM-14 items. Significant time effects occurred for management safety priority and ability (dimension 1, P=0.001), management safety empowerment (dimension 2, P=0.001), workers’ safety priority and risk non-acceptance (dimension 5, P=0.008), and peer safety communication, learning, and trust (dimension 6, P<0.001). SafePHM-14 practices improved over time for collaborative effort (item 1, P=0.005), equipment use (item 4, P=0.004), policy and guideline use (items 5–7, all P<0.001), risk assessment (item 8, P<0.001), patient mobility assessment (item 11, P=0.036), training (item 13, P<0.001), and injury-prevention discussions (item 14, P<0.001). Conclusions: The multifactorial intervention was not more effective than the single intervention in improving safety climate related to PHM. Safety climate and PHM practices nevertheless improved over time in both groups. Given the minimal additional benefit, the value of implementing the more resource-intensive multifactorial intervention may be questioned.
Publisher
Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health
Published On
Authors
Sebastian Buck, Jan Sandqvist, Emma Nilsing Strid, Nadine Karlsson, Paul Enthoven, Maria Andreassen, Charlotte Wåhlin
Tags
Safe patient handling and movementSafety climateHealthcare worker safetyCluster randomized controlled trialNursing homesInjury preventionSwedish healthcare
Listen, Learn & Level Up
Over 10,000 hours of research content in 25+ fields, available in 22+ languages.
No more digging through PDFs, just hit play and absorb the world's latest research in your language, on your time.
listen to research audio papers with researchbunny